Online car selling can be fast and rewarding—but only if you avoid the traps set by scammers. Here’s what to watch out for, and how to protect yourself.
The Most Common Car Selling Scams (And How They Work)
When selling a car online, you may encounter scams designed to trick you out of your vehicle or your money. Below are the most common schemes, how they work, and how to avoid them.
1. Fake Escrow Services
Scammers impersonate trusted companies and tell you funds are being held in a “secure” third-party escrow. But these sites are fake, and once you send the car—or a deposit—it’s gone.
How to avoid: Use only well-known, independently verified escrow services. Never use one recommended by the buyer unless you confirm its legitimacy.
2. Overpayment Scams
The scammer “accidentally” overpays you and asks for the difference back. The payment is later reversed or never clears, and you’re left out the refund.
How to avoid: Never accept payment for more than the agreed price. Don’t send any refunds until funds are 100% cleared.
3. Identity Theft
Scammers may ask for your license, bank info, or other sensitive data—just to “verify the deal.” They’re really out to steal your identity.
How to avoid: Only share the bare minimum required to complete the sale, and never send sensitive data through unsecured messages.
4. Wire Transfer Traps
Fraudsters insist on wire transfers to lock you into an irreversible payment method. They disappear as soon as the funds are sent.
How to avoid: Use safer options like cashier’s checks from verified banks or secured payment platforms.
5. Sight-Unseen Buyers
Scammers claim they’re out of town or too busy and want to buy the car without seeing it. They often send fake transporters and forged payments.
How to avoid: Require an in-person inspection or video call before any sale.
6. Phishing Sites and Fake Listings
Some buyers send you to fake vehicle report websites or clones of real car marketplaces to steal your login info or get you to pay for fake services.
How to avoid: Stick to known sites like Carfax, and never buy vehicle history reports from unknown sources.
7. Affiliate-Driven “Best Buyer” Lists
Many articles claiming to rank the “best car buyers” are nothing more than affiliate schemes. The sites earn commissions—not credibility.
How to avoid: Be skeptical of “top 10” lists with affiliate links. Do your own research and verify buyer reviews.
8. Dealer Networks Masquerading as Options
Some websites appear to show multiple buyers but really send every lead to the same underlying company—just to collect a referral fee.
How to avoid: Look for transparency in how offers are sourced. If a dozen sites show the same company behind the scenes, it’s not a marketplace—it’s a commission funnel.
9. Fake Damage Scams
Some scammers show up to view your car and create fake issues—pouring oil into the coolant reservoir or staging leaks—to lowball your price.
How to avoid: Meet in daylight at a secure public location. Keep a witness with you. And never allow potential buyers to tamper with the vehicle.
10. Fraudulent Payment Plans
A scammer agrees to pay in installments, starts with one or two, then vanishes. Without a binding contract, you’re left unpaid and without your car.
How to avoid: Require full payment up front. If you offer payment plans, use a legally binding contract and verify ID.
🔒 How to Protect Yourself When Selling Online
- Meet in safe, public places—preferably police parking lots.
- Remove personal info from documents and service records.
- Don’t accept personal checks or wire transfers from strangers.
- Never rush. Scammers thrive on urgency.
- Document every step—texts, emails, phone numbers, buyer IDs.
- File a release of liability or remove registration immediately after the sale.
💡 Why Sell My Car Online Is a Safer Choice
Most platforms are either affiliates pushing a buyer for a commission or part of the same buyer network. At Sell My Car Online, we’re different. We’re the express lane to selling any car for cash—no scams, no games.
- ✅ We verify every buyer in our network before allowing offers.
- ✅ You get multiple real offers, not rerouted to the same buyer.
- ✅ No surprise fees, lowball tricks, or bait-and-switch tactics.
- ✅ Instant online quotes, free pickup, and secure payments.
- ✅ Transparent process—what you see is what you get.
See how our offers compare and why we’re often the top-paying service online.
Bottom Line: Know the Scams—Choose Safety
Whether it’s overpayment, affiliate manipulation, or fake buyers with scripts, online car selling scams are evolving. Your best defense is awareness—and choosing a transparent, verified platform like Sell My Car Online.
Ready to sell without the scams? Get your instant offer now.
Get Your Offer
